252 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays
As of Nov 16, 2026
Oldest first. Older records come from published histories, guides, directories and ads; recent records come from the atlas's licences, inspections, chamber lists and State filings. A State filing shows when a company registered, not when a shop opened. A gap is a gap in the record, not proof the building was empty.
Zoning district: Resort Waterfront Business.
Older records, oldest first
From published histories, guides, directories and ads. Numbers in brackets point to the sources at the bottom of the page.
- date not given William Warner's grocery store groceryNo date given; placed in the order the Town's historic profile gives [1]
- 1993 to 2006 New York Seafood Council trade associationListed in guidebooks: 1993, 2003; listed in a 2006 directory [2] [3] [4]
- 1995 to 2000 Indian Cove Seafood Market seafood marketListed in local guides: 1995, 1999–2000 [5] [6] [7] business page
- 2005 Seafood marketIn the Town's historic profile [1]
- 2006 Brewster's Seafood Market seafood marketListed in a 2006 local guide [8] [9] business page
Recent records in the atlas
Licences, inspections, chamber lists, State filings and other current public records.
- Indian Cove Seafood Market 2002 to 2004 Not known Grocery
- BREWSTER'S SEAFOOD MARKET 2007 to 2015 Closed RestaurantState liquor licence 2013 to 2015 [10]
- Out of the Blue Seafood 2015 to now Open GroceryState liquor licence since 2024 · State food safety inspection 2026 [11] [12]
Sources
- Historic Profile of Hampton Bays, Phase I: Good Ground / Montauk Highway Corridor, Town of Southampton (with Hampton Bays Historical & Preservation Society), 2005 · source
- Magnuson Act and seafood safety : hearing before the Subcommittee on Fisheries Management of the Committee on Merchant M, Internet Archive, 1993 · source
- Cooking lighthouse style : favorite recipes from coast to coast, Internet Archive, 2003 · source
- National Directory of Nonprofit Organizations, Internet Archive, 2006 · source
- Hampton Handbook, Internet Archive, 1995 · source
- Jodi's Shortcuts '99 The Hamptons, Internet Archive, 1999 · source
- Jodi's Shortcuts 2000 - The Hamptons, Internet Archive, 2000 · source
- HEP guide to Long Island farmstands : farmers markets, CSA, and local purveyors, Internet Archive, 2006 · source
- Jodi's Shortcuts 2006, Internet Archive, 2006 · source
- NYS Liquor Authority licences, New York State (data.ny.gov) (Oct 23, 2013) · source
- NYS Liquor Authority licences, New York State (data.ny.gov) (Oct 30, 2024) · source
- NYS Agriculture and Markets food safety inspections, New York State (data.ny.gov) (Jul 10, 2026) · source