252 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

As of Nov 16, 2026

Oldest first. Older records come from published histories, guides, directories and ads; recent records come from the atlas's licences, inspections, chamber lists and State filings. A State filing shows when a company registered, not when a shop opened. A gap is a gap in the record, not proof the building was empty.

Zoning district: Resort Waterfront Business.

Older records, oldest first

From published histories, guides, directories and ads. Numbers in brackets point to the sources at the bottom of the page.

  1. date not given William Warner's grocery store groceryNo date given; placed in the order the Town's historic profile gives [1]
  2. 1993 to 2006 New York Seafood Council trade associationListed in guidebooks: 1993, 2003; listed in a 2006 directory [2] [3] [4]
  3. 1995 to 2000 Indian Cove Seafood Market seafood marketListed in local guides: 1995, 1999–2000 [5] [6] [7] business page
  4. 2005 Seafood marketIn the Town's historic profile [1]
  5. 2006 Brewster's Seafood Market seafood marketListed in a 2006 local guide [8] [9] business page

Recent records in the atlas

Licences, inspections, chamber lists, State filings and other current public records.

  1. Indian Cove Seafood Market 2002 to 2004 Not known Grocery
  2. BREWSTER'S SEAFOOD MARKET 2007 to 2015 Closed RestaurantState liquor licence 2013 to 2015 [10]
  3. Out of the Blue Seafood 2015 to now Open GroceryState liquor licence since 2024 · State food safety inspection 2026 [11] [12]

Sources

  1. Historic Profile of Hampton Bays, Phase I: Good Ground / Montauk Highway Corridor, Town of Southampton (with Hampton Bays Historical & Preservation Society), 2005 · source
  2. Magnuson Act and seafood safety : hearing before the Subcommittee on Fisheries Management of the Committee on Merchant M, Internet Archive, 1993 · source
  3. Cooking lighthouse style : favorite recipes from coast to coast, Internet Archive, 2003 · source
  4. National Directory of Nonprofit Organizations, Internet Archive, 2006 · source
  5. Hampton Handbook, Internet Archive, 1995 · source
  6. Jodi's Shortcuts '99 The Hamptons, Internet Archive, 1999 · source
  7. Jodi's Shortcuts 2000 - The Hamptons, Internet Archive, 2000 · source
  8. HEP guide to Long Island farmstands : farmers markets, CSA, and local purveyors, Internet Archive, 2006 · source
  9. Jodi's Shortcuts 2006, Internet Archive, 2006 · source
  10. NYS Liquor Authority licences, New York State (data.ny.gov) (Oct 23, 2013) · source
  11. NYS Liquor Authority licences, New York State (data.ny.gov) (Oct 30, 2024) · source
  12. NYS Agriculture and Markets food safety inspections, New York State (data.ny.gov) (Jul 10, 2026) · source